by DCScrap, Our Book of Scrap
History is full of great debate. Questions that remain unanswered like “what came first the chicken or the egg?” or “can you get pregnant through anal?” Luckily for you – the huddled masses – Epic Carnival is here to settle these arguments once and for all. House of Mirrors is your favorite Carnies taking a look at one another and debating the mysteries of the universe. This week the EC writers debate “Who is your favorite athlete of all time, and why?”
Sterling Gould, More Credible: My favorite athlete of all time has to be Percy Harvin (figures right?). I suppose because I actually met him in person and I had a premonition that he was on his way to stardom at the University of Florida. I love how he plays, 100% at all time and the fact he can line up anywhere on the field and be effective. I took a picture of him and I, it’s pretty much the coolest picture ever.
The heart surrounding it wasn’t put there by me. I promise.
Adam Best, Arrowhead Addict: No contest — Reggie Miller. Growing up as a tall, skinny, mouthy little sh**, I identified with Reggie. What separated Reg from other athletes was his ability to thrive under pressure. He played better in the playoffs than the regular season, and better in the fourth quarter than the previous three. Not only did he possess the ability to takeover games, he often willed his Indiana Pacers to victory with last-minute heroics. Did I write heroics? I meant miracles. How did a kid who was born with leg deformities — he had to wear Forrest Gump-like leg braces for several years as a child — run circles around the competition? I don’t know, but Reggie did it for 18 years, and he did it for only one team. Both his dedication and loyalty were unique, and are traits that aren’t often found in today’s fickle sports landscape. And, c’mon, you watch TNT — dude’s one cool cat.
dswinder, Sons of Sam Malone: My favorite athlete of all-time is…Surprise, surprise…Tiger Woods.
The obvious, and very bandwagonish answer as to why — THE MAN IS UN-BE-FRIKKIN’-LIEVABLE! He’s on pace to shatter the all-time wins record, he has a smokin’ hot wife, and craps silver dollars and then wipes with Benjamins.
The 100% honest answer — I remember watching him win the Masters in ‘97. I had been interested in golf for awhile by then thanks to my granddad, but if there was any question as to my future as an obsessive fan of the game, that final Sunday sealed the deal and locked me in. Everything about it amazed me; from the margin of victory to the fist pump. Tiger was young, likable, and ready to take over the game. Even as a kid, I could just tell there was something special about him.
Now, I live and die with every shot the man takes. I literally hold my breath every time he takes the club away, and I feel no shame.
Brian P. Foley, The College Baseball Blog: Cam Neely.
This guy was the best power forward in Hockey during the early 90’s. He made the Bruins relevant in Boston with his grit and his great skill on the ice. He just played with so much heart and is still a great guy in the community. He even scored 50 goals in 44 games in 1993-94 season.
Simon, SimonOnSports: My favorite athlete of all time is Chris Webber. Why because baggy shorts were cool and I was 9 so I picked up Michigan as a life long love. Nothing was sweeter than watching CWebb and the Wolverines fly up and down the court and dunk on every stupid Big Ten team. I followed him as a fan everywhere he’s gone which unfortunately does not include Tyra Banks’ Victoria’s Secrets. Plus, I have a sweet CWebb Bullets jersey.
DCScrap, Our Book of Scrap: Mine changes a lot, but until someone can do better than this ———————–>
He’s my fave.
DMtShooter, Five Tool Tool: Andrew Toney, shooting guard for the great Sixers’ teams of the early ’80s.
Andrew’s game was pure and perfect in its utter simplicity: he had a quicker first step than anyone who ever played basketball. So you either had to play off him and watch him nail jumpers with this fascinating cobra-twitch of a shot motion, or come out to guard him and watch him blow past you to the rack.
Andrew’s nickname was The Boston Strangler, which is also the coolest nickname ever. I will brook no arguments over this.
When Danny Ainge used to try to guard him, Andrew had this utter disdain in his body language, like he was insulted by Ainge’s very existence. (He wouldn’t be the last to have that reaction.) So the cobra strike would! hit, Ainge would flail and foul and look like the awkward awful white guy in your pick up game, and all would be well in the universe.
Sixer fans worshiped Julius Erving like a piece of art, admired Moses Malone for his sheer plowhorse rebounding, trust Mo Cheeks to always make the right play, and identify with the gawky defensive wonder that was Bobby Jones. But Andrew? We just loved him.
Like many of the treasured athletes in people’s memories, Andrew ended fast; persistent foot injuries and disagreements with the Sixers’ coaching and medical staff led him to a bitter and early retirement, and he hasn’t been back much since. I think this actually adds to his appeal, since no one ever had to watch him without all of his gifts, and the low profile adds to the mystery. In the early 90s, as I finally had enough scratch and the means to go to Sixers games on my own and the team was horrifying, I’d just imagine what things would be like if that 22 jersey came thr! ough the doors.
Since those ’80s teams were loaded and balanced , Andrew rarely had the big scoring averages that transcend the era; it’s rare to think of a guy with a career 15.9 scoring average as your favorite player ever. Which, well, makes it even better. You had to see him.
Don, With Malice…: David Campese, Australian Rugby Team (The Wallabies) winger.
Perhaps the best winger to ever play the game, Campo had an instinctive brilliance about him. He used his patented “goose step” – a high kick stutter-stepping motion – to befuddle defenders, and get past pretty much anyone the game had to offer. Hailed by even his opponents as amazing, in his first tour of rugby powerhouse New Zealand, even their legendary winger Stu Wilson was said to have nightmares about Campese – and Campo at the ripe ol’ age of 19.
In later years, his zig-zag run at Welsh center Robert Ackerman in Cardiff, Wales is considered to be pure artistry – even the home crowd leapt to their feet to applaud… and at this stage he’s only 22 (clip of Campese turning Ackerman left & right).
Campese was brilliant, daring… but also flawed. The risks he took sometimes didn’t pay dividends, tho’ more often than not they did. He sums up what’s great about Australian rugby – the slashing back, the devil-may-care run.
Liston, Introducing Liston: My favorite athlete of all time is Jesus Christ. He was/will be a stud (again). Now, I know that we don’t have any actual proof that Jesus played any sports (Is getting crucified a sport?), but could anybody conceivably be better at anything, let alone sports, than the Son of God? Maybe Tim Duncan, but that’s about it. Come to think of it, yes, Tim Duncan is probably better than Jesus at everything. I mean, he’s Timothy-frigg’n-Duncan! He’s won like, a thousand championship and scored about a billion points! I’ve changed my mind. Forget Jesus, my favorite athlete of all time is Tim Duncan.
So, who is your favorite, and why?